How to compare hiring demand using public job postings
Compare hiring demand using public job postings, consistent role and location criteria, and dated snapshots that show where the evidence is missing.
Free app. Runs on your Mac with the Claude or Codex plan you already have.
What hiring demand is
Hiring demand is an employer's need for people to fill roles. Public job postings give recruiting teams one observable part of that demand: the vacancies employers advertise on the sources you can inspect. A useful comparison counts distinct ads for a defined role, location, and set of employers as of a stated date. It preserves the source links and coverage so you can see where the findings apply and use them to plan the next recruiting decision.
This kind of labor market analysis works best with a precise question. You may want to understand where peers are advertising for a role you need to fill, or which employers mention a location often enough to justify a closer review. Role titles, remote policies, and posting practices vary. Set the rules before collecting the ads, read enough of the original notices to apply them consistently, and keep limitations visible when you summarize the result.
What it does for the business
- Put sourcing time where it can inform a searchSee where comparable employers are advertising for work similar to yours. Recruiters can use the result to decide which locations deserve a closer look and where they need more direct evidence about candidate supply.
- Improve the language of a job briefA set of relevant ads gives the hiring manager examples of titles, responsibilities, and experience descriptions used for comparable work. Use those examples to make the role easier for qualified candidates to recognize.
- Prepare for competing searchesVisible activity among selected employers gives the hiring team a concrete list of postings to discuss. That discussion can shape sourcing priorities and interview capacity while the team confirms what the ads actually represent.
- Plan a repeatable market reviewSave the employer and role scope so the next comparison starts from the same baseline. When a source drops out, the team can explain why a change is unavailable and decide which evidence is worth restoring.
Hiring demand, step by step
Define the comparison and the counting unit
A vacancy count makes sense only when the reader knows which employers, roles, and locations it covers.
What to do
- Write the recruiting decision in one sentence. For example, choose two locations to investigate for a senior support search, then name the employers you want to compare in both places.
- Define which titles and duties belong to the role. Note neighboring jobs, seniority levels, and employment types that would change the interpretation. Leave room for equivalent titles when the duties make the match clear.
- Set a location rule before reading the ads. Decide how you will handle remote roles, hybrid roles, and ads that name several offices. Use the same rule for each employer.
- Decide what counts as one observation and record the reference date. Keep an advertisement for several unspecified hires as one distinct ad unless the source provides separately identifiable openings.
Why
A difference between employers can come from your selection rules as easily as from the postings. A vague role can mix specialists and managers, and a remote opening may otherwise appear as local demand in several places. A fixed definition lets another recruiter repeat the work and identify the cases that depend on judgment.
Collect traceable records from employer postings
A count is reviewable when every included vacancy can be traced to an observed posting.
What to do
- Start with the selected employers' careers pages or their official public job boards. Use directories and aggregators to discover possible ads, then open the employer posting for the records you rely on.
- Capture the exact posting URL, job ID where visible, role title, employer, location, and observation time. Record the closing or validity date if the employer provides it and leave it unknown otherwise.
- Read enough of each posting to apply the role and location rules. Keep a short note on borderline cases so someone can see why a broad title, announced remote policy, or multi-office ad was included.
- Log unavailable boards and any part of a source you could not inspect. Record when you used a saved copy and the date it represents so the reader can distinguish it from a fresh observation.
Why
A search result or copied listing can be older than the employer's own posting, and an incomplete source can make a company appear quieter than it is. Original links and dates let the reviewer check the evidence. The source log shows whether a thin count reflects the job ads you actually found or a gap in collection.
Count distinct ads and compare compatible snapshots
A change in observed postings is interpretable only when both snapshots measure the same thing.
What to do
- Apply posting deduplication, the process of counting repeated copies of the same ad once. Use an employer job ID or canonical posting link first and inspect similar titles manually when IDs differ or are missing.
- Review ads with multiple locations or different office links before adding counts. If you group by location, document any overlap so readers know how to interpret totals across places.
- Group the qualifying observations by employer and location. Check the rows with the largest counts and make sure a copied ad, a repost, or a location rule did not inflate them.
- To review hiring trends by role, match the role, locations, employers, and source scope across dates and check coverage for both snapshots. Use the first usable snapshot as a baseline and withhold the change if one side is incomplete.
Why
Recruiters can use a dated change to decide which employers or locations deserve another look, provided they know what was counted. A prior snapshot reflects postings observed at that earlier date. When coverage changes, a raw difference can reflect a missing page or a different employer list, leaving the direction of change unresolved.
Deliver the comparison for recruiting review
A hiring comparison should state what was observed and what decision still needs evidence.
What to do
- Lead with the strongest supported finding in the table. Name the role, location, employers, and observation date, and describe the differences as published ad observations within that scope.
- Show the observed counts, available source links, and any gaps that affect a decision. Explain whether the result is a baseline or a comparable change and make any overlapping location counts easy to spot.
- Open a leading source and reconstruct its count from the retained ads. Read any postings that could change the conclusion if reassigned to a different role or location.
- Have a qualified recruiting or HR reviewer treat the comparison as a draft. Ask them to verify the key posting links and combine them with other evidence before changing a sourcing or staffing plan.
Why
Recruiting market research is easier to use when an HR reviewer can see exactly what the numbers represent. An observed vacancy count can point to employers and locations for a closer review. Final decisions may also need information about candidate availability, how quickly roles must be filled, and actual responses to your sourcing efforts.
Common mistakes
- Counting the same ad from several sitesCheck the employer's posting ID or canonical page and keep one observation for each distinct ad.
- Matching solely on broad job titlesRead the described work before combining jobs whose titles overlap but whose responsibilities differ.
- Counting remote jobs as local demand everywhereApply a stated rule for remote and multi-location ads and flag overlap among location totals.
- Treating an unreadable board as zero vacanciesRecord the inaccessible source and withhold a change that depends on complete coverage.
- Presenting advertised vacancies as hiring intentionsDescribe what employers published and give the reader the observation scope and date.
What a good result looks like
- The role, locations, employers, source list, and observation date are clear.
- A reviewer can find the original postings behind the reported counts.
- Duplicates, ambiguous titles, and multi-location jobs follow consistent rules.
- Baseline, comparable change, and missing evidence are easy to recognize.
- The finding identifies a concrete follow-up for a recruiting or HR reviewer.
And then what? Using the result
- Have recruiting inspect the most relevant ads and check whether their role definitions match the search you plan to run.
- Share wording examples with the hiring manager and revise role titles or descriptions where it improves clarity.
- Use the observed locations to choose where to test sourcing, then compare the actual candidate responses.
- Save the sources and counting rules, and assign someone to restore missing coverage before the next comparison.
When to run it
- Before opening a search in several locationsCompare the same role and employers across locations to decide which places merit deeper sourcing research.
- When setting a recruiting review scheduleEstablish a baseline with fixed sources and criteria so a later team can repeat the comparison.
- When job titles make comparable roles hard to findRead postings across organizations to see which titles describe the responsibilities you actually need.
- When a repeat run shows a dropCheck the source coverage and original ads before discussing what changed with the hiring team.
Questions people ask
How do you compare hiring demand across employers?
Count distinct observed postings for the same role and location criteria across a stated group of employers. Keep the source links and observation date so a reviewer can verify what each count covers.
Can job postings measure total hiring demand?
Job postings measure visible advertising activity in the sources you inspect. Estimates of total demand need broader evidence about employers and openings beyond those ads.
How do you avoid counting the same job twice?
Use the employer's job ID or canonical posting link to combine repeated copies of the same ad. Review likely duplicates by employer, title, location, and description when those identifiers are missing.
When can you compare hiring snapshots over time?
Compare them when the role, geographic and employer criteria, and source scope match and coverage is complete on both dates. Describe the change in observed ads and identify the dates used.
What should you do if a job board is unavailable?
Record the source gap and preserve any usable observations from accessible boards. Withhold comparisons that need the missing evidence and identify what would let you complete them.
How should you handle one job advertised in several locations?
Keep the unique posting identity and apply the same location rule across employers. If the same ad contributes to several location groups, disclose the overlap before anyone sums the groups.
More jobs in Research
Compare hiring demand, on your own Mac.Free app. Runs on your Mac with the Claude or Codex plan you already have. Your files stay on your computer.
Download for Mac