How to do a backlink audit and decide which links to fix
Run a backlink audit by checking where links appear and where they land. Learn which links to keep, which targets to fix, and when to ask for updates.
Free app. Runs on your Mac with the Claude or Codex plan you already have.
What a backlink audit is
A backlink audit reviews links from other websites to yours. You start with an export or a sample, look for patterns, and open selected pages to check where each link appears and where it sends visitors. The result gives you verified links, an ordered list of fixes, and a record of what still needs inspection.
Your backlink profile is the collection of links pointing to your site. Each export captures the links its provider found and chose to include. Read the scope and date before drawing conclusions. Keep observations from live pages alongside the provider's data. When a source refuses to load, record the gap so a later reviewer can see what remains uncertain.
What it does for the business
- Recover visits from existing linksBroken backlinks can interrupt visits people already intended to make. If a partner's setup instructions still point to a retired page, a redirect to the current guide can get those readers back to the instructions they came for.
- Give partners a specific update to makeAn editor can act on a request that names the article, the outdated link, and the URL that now serves the reader. That makes link reclamation, the work of recovering lost or misdirected links, easier to assign and follow up.
- Spend review time on evidence that can change a decisionGive the account team a short queue ordered by the likely value of a closer look. An inaccessible product review can go near the top if it may still send readers to the client's retired offer.
- Find pages to promoteCompare linked destinations with the pages your team wants readers to find. A current reference guide with few links in the export gives you a concrete asset to pitch to partners whose resources cover the same subject.
Backlink audit, step by step
Define the scope and clean up the export
A link count makes sense once the reader knows what each row represents.
What to do
- Record the site or section you are reviewing, the export provider, the export date, and which fields are available. Keep a copy of the raw export so another reviewer can trace a row back to the source.
- Use a consistent row definition. Count a link once for each unique combination of linking page, target address, and anchor text, which is the visible wording of the link. Mark unknown anchor data as missing.
- Count linking sites separately as referring domains. Keep distinct source pages in the working table, even when they share a domain or the same navigation template.
- If you lack an export, search for mentions of the domain, brand, products, and titles of important pages. Look at named partners and press coverage as well. Save the queries and label the findings as a sample.
Why
A partner with a footer link across its site can account for many link rows and still be a single referring domain. Keeping both counts shows what drives the total. Preserving missing fields also matters because an export with no anchor column cannot support a conclusion about how often other sites use your brand in link text.
Check the links and their destinations
Follow the link to see what a reader gets.
What to do
- Look across the file for domains that account for many links, groups of similar anchors, and heavily linked target pages. Start with representative pages from the most common domains, then open unusual sources and entries that could affect an action.
- Check how links are distributed between the home page and deeper pages. Flag important resources with few or no links in the export, and look for sudden gains or losses if the data includes dates.
- On each source page, look for the link and note its placement in the article, author line, comments, directory, or repeating navigation. Record the visible wording and any nofollow, sponsored, or ugc labels, which identify how the publisher marks the link.
- Read the material around the link. Check whether the referring page covers the same subject, who publishes it, and whether the placement looks copied across pages. Record what you can see and keep provider-reported details labeled separately.
- Follow the link and record the final address, a loading failure, or any redirect. Read the resulting page to see whether it answers what the source led readers to expect. Mark an inaccessible source as could not open.
Why
Readers following a reference to a setup guide expect to land on instructions. A home page may load successfully and leave them looking for the guide. Check the destination in the context of what the linking page promises.
Assign a verdict to every opened link
A verdict should tell the next person what to do and cite the evidence behind it.
What to do
- Keep relevant links that appear in the text of real publications and record what makes each link useful. Mark isolated spam or odd-looking links as harmless when the evidence gives you no reason to act.
- For a broken or misdirected target, name the old URL and a live replacement that serves the same purpose. If the equivalent is unclear, ask the site owner to check the replacement before making the change.
- Request an update when an editor can fix a missing link, an old name or address, or a home page link that would be more helpful on a specific page. Save the contact route you found and draft a short request naming both the article and the proposed destination.
- Mark links that have disappeared from accessible pages as gone. If the page was inaccessible, preserve that verdict. Put unopened sources in priority order and explain what decision each inspection might change.
- Examine repeated exact commercial phrases across unrelated sites and any evidence of paid link placement. Treat a provider score or matching phrase as a lead to investigate, and record the evidence you found for your risk judgment.
Why
Fixing a destination you own can restore visits from several sources in one change. A verdict based on what you observed helps the team decide which other links justify outreach.
Recheck the evidence behind proposed changes
Every proposed fix should survive a second look at the pages behind it.
What to do
- Recount link rows and domains from the raw file using the original row definition. Check whether duplicates, missing fields, and dates were handled consistently.
- Reopen the sources behind redirect fixes, update requests, and gone verdicts. Follow the links again and confirm that each proposed replacement page still loads and serves the same purpose.
- Compare the report's pattern claims with the rows that support them. Use gain or loss dates only where the export provides them, and distinguish a small observed group from a sitewide finding.
- Record how many rows you read and pages you opened. Name the sources you could not access and the evidence that is still needed before anyone acts on an uncertain link.
Why
A site can change between export and review. If the publisher has already updated a link, a request would waste their time. Rechecking the evidence and the count gives your client a way to verify why an action made the list.
Hand off the fixes and the remaining decisions
Start the handoff with the action the site owner can take first.
What to do
- Lead with the main finding and the first change. Name the owner, the URL, and what to verify.
- List redirect fixes first, then update requests, then pages worth promoting to earn new links.
- Include the verdict table and inspection queue with a date and a description of the evidence you covered.
Why
The person approving a redirect or assigning outreach needs to trace the decision back to the source. Keep that evidence with the action so they can check it before proceeding.
Common mistakes
- Counting every exported row as a separate endorsementRepeated footer links and duplicate records can make one source look like broad support.
- Treating missing fields as zeroA blank provider score or anchor cell only tells you the export lacks that value.
- Deciding from a toxic link check aloneUse the score to select pages for inspection and base any recommendation on observed evidence.
- Assuming every successful redirect worksRead the destination to check that it answers the promise made on the linking page.
- Turning a blocked page into a bad verdictRecord the access failure and preserve the need for another check if that link could change the recommendation.
What a good result looks like
- A dated source inventory with separate link and domain totals.
- Verified verdicts backed by the observed source, link placement, and destination.
- Fixes with the old URL and a suitable live replacement.
- Update requests with a source page, contact route where available, and proposed wording.
- A prioritized queue and a plain statement of what the audit could verify.
And then what? Using the result
- Give your developer the redirect fixes and check the old URLs after deployment.
- Send approved update requests and revisit the source pages after editors reply.
- Use the linked pages and placements that serve readers well to choose which resource to pitch next.
- Return to the highest priority unopened sources as new exports or page access become available.
When to run it
- After a site migrationFind which old addresses still receive links and check whether they redirect to equivalent pages. Start with sources that readers have a clear reason to follow, such as links in setup guides.
- When taking over a client siteUse a dated export and a documented sample to establish what the client has and where you can make the first repairs.
- When an export shows an unfamiliar link patternOpen representative sources to see whether the rows reflect a common template, editorial links, or placements that warrant closer review.
Questions people ask
How do you do a backlink audit?
Start with a dated export or a labeled public sample, then open selected sources and confirm where their links lead. Record a verdict for each checked link, order the supported fixes and update requests, and give unopened sources their own inspection queue.
What is the difference between backlinks and referring domains?
Backlinks are individual links to your site. Referring domains are the distinct sites those links come from. If three articles from one publisher link to your guide, they contribute three backlinks and one referring domain under a count grouped by site.
What does anchor text tell you in an audit?
Anchor text shows how a source describes a link to its readers. An identical sales phrase across unrelated sites is a reason to open the sources and check the surrounding content.
How should you use a toxic link check?
Use a toxic link check to choose which sources to review. Judge what you find from the placement, context, and destination. Record evidence of coordinated commercial wording or purchased links before drawing a risk conclusion.
When should you consider a disavow file?
Consider a disavow file if the search engine has sent a manual-action notice about links. A disavow file asks a search engine to disregard specified links. Review the notice and the verified link evidence before deciding which action it calls for.
Can you audit backlinks without a paid tool?
Yes, start with the external link exports in Google Search Console if you have access to the site. Save the Latest links and More sample links exports. If you cannot get an export, collect examples through public search and state the limits of that sample in the report.
More jobs in SEO agencies
Backlink audit with AI, on your own Mac.Free app. Runs on your Mac with the Claude or Codex plan you already have. Your files stay on your computer.
Download for Mac